You may have noticed more deodorant options labeled as “aluminum free” as you do your groceries. You may have even noticed a demand for safer and natural products.
Even browsing through beauty blogs will reveal a list of “all-natural” products you could switch to. But what is it about aluminum and why is it bad when included as a deodorant ingredient?
Why is there aluminum in deodorants?
To be fair, the use of the term deodorant to mean anything used to swipe on underarms is inaccurate. There are two underarm products that do two different things: deodorants and antiperspirants.
Deodorants lessen body odor due to its fragrance or antibacterial compounds. Antiperspirants, on the other hand, control your sweating and for that, it needs aluminum.
Aluminum salts, in particular, are part of an antiperspirant concoction and are responsible for plugging pores to reduce sweat. In addition, they also control body odor by restraining sweat-loving bacteria.
Why is aluminum so concerning to a lot of people?
There are two health concerns linked to the fear surrounding aluminum: breast cancer and Alzheimer’s disease.
Concerns about the connection of Alzheimer’s and aluminum first appeared around the 60s and 70s when aluminum was identified as a reason for someone developing Alzheimer’s.
Those concerns were magnified in 1985 when the brains of Alzheimer’s patients were found to have high levels of aluminum. A 1990 study arrived at the same conclusion but that research was discredited because data was taken from other people, not patients.
The concern over aluminum having to do with breast cancer stems from the fact that the breasts are closely located to the underarms. The belief is that aluminum gets into the lymph nodes then make their way to the breasts.
In addition, there were also fears that not being able to sweat (remember that aluminum blocks pores) won’t release cancerous substances. However, sweating doesn’t release all toxins; instead, it’s your body’s way of regulating temperature.
The filtering of toxins and other harmful substances are done by the kidneys and liver. So if a study linking aluminum to Alzheimer’s was discredited and no proven link between aluminum and breast cancer was found, what is all the fuss about?
Being health conscious is not a crime
We all want what’s best for our bodies, from the food we consume to the products we apply on our skin.
If someone is concerned about the potentially harmful effects of chemicals and other ingredients in deodorants, it is their very right to want to choose a more natural option.
And this is where we are at with aluminum-free products. With the growing demand for safe and natural beauty products, how can one choose which is the best for them?
Frankly, deodorant choice all boils down to suitability since not everyone is the same. Some products will work on others, while some won’t.
On that note, here are some recommendations for aluminum-free products that you can try to determine which one is the most effective in curbing odor:
The Most Effective: Malin + Goetz Eucalyptus Deodorant
The Second Best: PitROK Crystal Unscented Deodorant Spray
The Somewhat Effective: Salt of the Earth Crystal Classic Deodorant Stick
5 Best Deodorants Without Aluminum
1. Malin + Goetz Eucalyptus Deodorant
The size might be burdensome for those who want to carry it around for reapplications, but it’s a minor complaint compared to what the product can do for you.
Described as a “deodorant with a cult following,” it’s easy to see the appeal of the product. The minimalist design, effective odor curbing, and fresh scent make it a hit with all-natural advocates.
One of the best things about the Malin + Goetz deodorant is that it feels really clean when applied to your underarm. You won’t see that dreaded white residue on your skin.
On top of that, it won’t even leave stains on your clothes. But you will have to go through an adjustment period with this product.
It might take as long as two weeks for your body to warm up to this natural deodorant. So if you’re not that patient, this might not be the best choice for you.
- It is an effective deodorant.
- It doesn’t leave any white residue on underarms.
- It doesn’t stain clothes.
- It has a fresh scent.
- It might take time for the body to get used to this deodorant, making the product not wholly effective when first used.
2. PitROK Crystal Unscented Deodorant Spray
PitRock deodorant also uses aloe vera and grapefruit seed extract to leave your skin feeling fresh all day long. While some prefer a hint of scent in their deodorant, this one is fragrance-free which suits those who like unscented varieties.
One major complaint with this deodorant is that it doesn’t really stick once sprayed. The liquid tends to roll off, requiring the need for your hands to rub it on your underarms.
Other than that, it is an effective product for odor control. Plus, it doesn’t leave stains and white residue.
- It is best for those with sensitive skin.
- It uses natural mineral salts for odor protection.
- It provides day-long protection.
- It doesn’t leave a yucky white residue.
- It doesn’t stain clothes.
- It doesn’t stick when sprayed; a little help is needed to rub the deodorant in.
3. Salt of the Earth Crystal Classic Deodorant Stick
The same concept applies in stick version. You have to wet the tip but make sure that your skin is absolutely dry, otherwise, it will stink up the stone.
Once applied, the really tiny layer of mineral salts will stop the growth of bacteria that causes foul smells. It’s that simple and is available in a travel size variant.
However, a word of caution: people go about their lives differently and that may affect the product’s effectiveness. It may work well for those who stay indoors a lot and thus don’t require a lot of sweating.
The product is also effective during cold weather or winter months when you don’t have to sweat a lot. Then again, some people who sweat a lot and live in humid climates take to the product rather well.
In short, using this product can be a hit or a miss, but it’s a good option if you want to go the all-natural route. Plus, it leaves none of that icky white residue present in other deodorant varieties.
Another word of advice on this one: it will sting when used right after shaving.
- It’s an all-natural solution to preventing body odor.
- It comes in a travel size container.
- It does not leave white residue on your underarms.
- It may not be as effective for everyone, especially those who sweat a lot.
- It will hurt when applied after shaving.
4. Lavera Organic Roll-On Deodorant
You wouldn’t think bamboo and wild roses as ingredients in a deodorant, but those ingredients combined with other natural elements works. This deodorant offers 24-hour protection, meaning you don’t need to reapply this as you go about your day.
While the deodorant is effective, the trouble in its use lies with its application. You really have to be quite patient as it doesn’t dry quickly.
So this means that you have to get ready earlier than usual to allow this deodorant to dry. But that is a minor constraint for a product that can offer day-long protection.
A complaint that can be made against this deodorant is that it leaves a noticeable white residue. So it might not be the best option for those who like wearing clothes without sleeves.
- It provides day-long protection.
- It requires time to dry.
- It leaves a white residue.
5. Bionsen Pump Spray Deodorant
While effective, the fragrance can be quite overpowering. Not overpowering in the sense that you can’t take it, but in a way that drowns out whatever fragrance you’re wearing.
Other than that, it’s quite effective.
- It effectively keeps odor at bay.
- It has an overpowering scent that may interfere with fragrances you use.
Whatever your reasons for switching to an aluminum free product are, you might have to purchase one or more options before finding the right one.
Selecting the right deodorant that will best fit is a hit and miss process, but one that you hopefully won’t get frustrated by. It helps to be reminded that not everyone is the same and what works for others may not be the ideal option for you.
With this list, you will find potential options to try if you should want to join the aluminum free product movement.